|
Walsh, Véronique - Creatively Anti-Perfect **** Excellent demo album based around Véroniques usually-better-than
-when -she-sings-live vocals and acoustic guitar. I prefer the beautiful, moving ballads to the more forced up tempo songs.
A very good album. Released - 2000 Acquired by me: 28.10.00 - Present (Véronique)
Waterboys
– Book Of Lightning – Special Limited Edition **** The Waterboys
new album Book Of Lightning is an excellent introduction to one of favourite bands as it uniquely includes many of the musical
styles that lead Waterboy Mike Scot has pedalled over the last 20+ years. Not
that you would be able to tell this though from the opening tracks… The first three tracks The Crash Of Angel Wings,
Love Will Shoot You Down and Nobody’s Baby Anymore are a return to the mainstream rock of much of the 1993 LP Dream
Harder though some may also argue that they are a kind of modern version of the famously monikered Big Music of the 80s. New guitarist Leo Abrahams is consistently present with some fine clipped playing
but the fellow who fiddles Steve Wickham is almost entirely absent. Fortunately
though Wickham soon makes his highly talented presence felt as the album continues… Other tracks on Book Of Lightning
are more suited to Steve’s fiddle playing. These include folk-rock songs
in the vein of the Fisherman’s Blues LP, Mike Scott’s distinctive piano “ballads” and even a nod to
the more introverted style of his 90s solo LPs on the closing track The Man with The Wind At His Heels. Of the folk-rock songs, Everybody Takes A Tumble is destined to be a (live) Waterboys classic with its
catchy fiddle and organ reels. The other lengthy song of similar style, She Tried
To Hold Me is also melodically memorable but contains some of the worst rhyming couplets ever written. The guess-the-next-line game reaches its zenith when Scott rhymes uranium with cranium! So cheesily bad it’s almost kind of good… Thankfully the lyrics are better on the piano-written
songs such as the nicely oblique Strange Arrangement and You In The Sky, originally released on the Collectors Edition of
Fisherman’s Blues in 2006 and newly rerecorded here. The other piano song,
the sparse Sustain includes an excellent piercing trumpet solo by long-time Waterboys alumni Roddy Lorimer. It’s good to hear him once again on a Waterboys record. Initial copies of the Book Of Lightning
LP include a special limited edition DVD, “The Travels Of The Waterboys: A
Unique Compendium Of The Band’s On Tour Home Movies”. A nice souvenir
though the hand-held cameras and snippets of songs grate a bit though a full acoustic live version of The Pan Within at the
end of the disc makes serious amends. It’s also strange though refreshing
to see serious man of mystery Mike Scott larking about so much in the film. Maybe
he is a kind of regular guy, albeit a very artistically talented one after all… Regular guy, artist or visionary,
Scott has produced an excellent album in Book Of Lightning with songs harking back to the various musical styles he has adopted
over the last 20 years. It’s not perfect yet the best moments are stunning
and superb and are well worth a place as an introduction or addition to the Waterboys product in your music collection. Released: 2007 Acquired by me: Bought (April
07)
Waterboys
– Fisherman’s Blues (Collectors Edition) ****1/2 After releasing
the majestic This Is The Sea in 1985, lead Waterboy Mike Scott realised that he couldn’t take the Big Music of his first
three LPs any further and sought a change in direction. Fortuitously, he met
the brilliant fiddler Steve Wickham at about the same time. Steve invited Mike
to Ireland for a week’s holiday – he ended up staying several years… From early 86 to mid 88, Mike, Steve,
Anthony Thistlethwaite and other assorted Waterboys recorded the songs which eventually found their way on to Fisherman’s
Blues. The Fisherman’s sessions are the stuff of legend with far more excellent
songs recorded than could be fitted onto the original LP. Mike Scott finally
came back to the recordings in the early noughties and released a second LP Too Close To Heaven in 2001. He has now dipped into the sessions again for a remastered version of the original album with a second
CD of further previously unreleased songs and versions. So are the songs on disc two worth their belated release? Definitely because they add further historical context to the Waterboys' Fisherman’s
period and include a handful of lost classics which are finally unearthed to the outside world. We finally get to hear the studio version of late 80s live favourite Meet Me At The Station as well as
the superb scratchy jazz-blues of If I Can’t Have You. Best of all perhaps
is the epic You In The Sky, a lost treasure liked so much by Scott that he has recorded a new version of it for the new Waterboys
LP Book of Lightning. As well as containing excellent music, the Collector’s Edition of Fisherman’s Blues is
also superbly packaged with an enlightening essay by Mike Scott on his lengthy Irish sojourn and musician credits and commentary
for every song. The Collector’s Edition is a fascinating document of a semi-legendary musical adventure and splendid souvenir for the Waterboys’
loyal fanbase. It is also a very worthy addition to the collection of any contemporary
or roots music fan. Released: 2006 Acquired by me: 11.10.06 (Present for Naomi)
Waterboys - Fisherman’s Blues **** In 1985, The Waterboys released the anthemic,
spiritual rock classic This Is The Sea and had a minor hit with The Whole Of The Moon. The world seemed to be theirs for the
taking with journalists and fans talking of them as the next U2. Everyone was very excited - everyone, that is, apart from
Waterboys mainman Mike Scott. Not wanting to follow the Gaelic stadium rock path and feeling that he couldn't top This Is
The Sea, Scott decamped to Ireland at the suggestion of his newish friend Steve Wickham and emerged over two years’
later with the very different folk-rock of Fisherman’s Blues. Many fans were at first shocked by this change of direction
though the real fans were won over with FB now being many people’s favourite Waterboys LP. Mike’s infatuation
with Ireland is everywhere on Fisherman’s Blues from the massive list of thanks you’s and deliberately dated packaging
to (of course) the music itself. The album begins with the brilliant four chord title track, probably The Waterboys’
second best known song. The rest of side one is a bit fragmented with two songs showing a slightly uneasy mix between their
old and new styles surrounding the beautiful Strange Boat, a live favourite to this day. Many of the songs on Fisherman’s
Blues began as jams, punctuated sporadically with recording sessions. Although the recording of the LP spans three major studio
periods between 1986 and 88, the album itself is pretty cohesive - especially on side two, all recorded in the final period.
Highlights here include the touching and humorous And A Bang On The Ear and Has Anybody Here Seen Hank? Mike Scott’s
supporting cast are on excellent form here as they are on the whole album with lead players Steve Wickham (fiddle) and
Anthony Thistlethwaite (saxophone, mandolin, harmonica and organ) particularly shining. With all the material recorded
during the Fisherman’s Blues sessions, it is perhaps surprising that the album contains only 12 songs including two
brief instrumentals, a traditional song and a cover of Van Morris's Sweet Thing. If it was re-released now, the Special Edition
would no doubt include a bonus disc of lost songs (2006 IT HAS AND IT DOES! - SEE ABOVE) though Scott has already pre-empted
this by releasing Too Close To Heaven: The Unreleased Fisherman's Blues Sessions in 2001. Nevertheless Fisherman’s
Blues is a very good albeit slightly inconsistent album, very significant in Mike Scott’s musical and spiritual journey
and one of the best LPs to bear his name.
Waterboys – Karma Burn **** Live albums were a standard climactic
release for rock bands in the 70s and early 80s but a rare commodity now. In
the old days, you were not really a major band till you had released a live LP – preferably a double album with extra
points still if recorded in Japan. Like most music fans today I have very mixed views on live albums. Sure there are some classics (Neil Young’s Live Rust is my favourite and Thin Lizzy’s
Live & Dangerous an acknowledged career high point) though they often don’t really capture the atmosphere of the
live experience. The extended guitar solo which was so exciting at the gig is
often tedious in the confines of the living room. The usually more satisfying
live video or DVD have now largely taken over as “product” for recording the live experience anyway… Cue
to The Waterboys Karma Burn which I suspect sadly is audio rather than audio-visual for purely economic reasons. The Waterboys are one of my favourite bands though KB does fall into some of the usual traps for live albums. This is not helped by the tracklisting – the first two tracks are each about
seven minutes long – nor the unwise decision to put their lengths on the back of the LP.
Casual listeners may be disheartened to see that they still have almost 10 minutes to go till the end of the song after
the man body of the epic Pan Within. If however, they persevere and listen whilst
in the right mood, they will be rewarded by some excellent music. Karma Burn was recorded at various venues in Britain
and Ireland from 2003-2004. It features the now established line-up of mainman
Mike Scott on vocals and guitar, the virtuoso Steve Wickham on fiddle and Richard Naiff on keyboards supported by the muscular
rhythm section of Steve Walters (bass) and Carlos Hercules (drums). The songs
chosen from the album draw on Scott’s long career with a sensible mix of the hits (Fisherman’s Blues, Glastonbury
Song and his most famous song, Whole Of The Moon) and more obscure choices (Open, My Dark Side and unfortunately, one of his
worst songs, The Return Of Jimi Hendrix). The lengthy Pan Within is a highlight
when in the mood for Mike’s extended electric guitar solo and though most of the rest of KB is excellent, there’s
little else here that is truly exciting. I would have probably preferred a few
more acoustic versions like the ones The Waterboys played when I saw them in 2003 and more tracks from Universal Hall – only Peace Of Iona is featured from the album the group were promoting on their
2003-4 tour. Having said this, Karma Burn is a very worthwhile purchase for a Waterboys fan though a studio compilation
is probably a better introduction for the uninitiated. The live album is a rare
breed these days and, although KB has its flaws, it’s better than many thoroughbreds and a worthy addition to Mike Scott’s
compelling body of work. Released: 2005 Acquired by me: 25.12.05 – Present (Naomi)
Waterboys,
The – This Is The Sea (Remastered 2 CD Edition) ****1/2 ”I have heard the big music and I’ll never be the same” sung Waterboys’ main man Mike Scott
on the band’s second LP A Pagan Place. Inadvertently but accurately labelling the band’s sound, the big music
reached its zenith on their following album This Is The Sea, a landmark album for the band and the musical era. Words frequently
used to describe The Waterboys sound in the mid 80s include majestic, inspiring, romantic and intense. They certainly had a big, powerful sound but a sense of musical adventure and couldn’t-care-less-about-the-charts
attitude which set them apart from lesser lights of the semi-Celtic 80s sound such as Simple Minds, Big Country and The Alarm. They also moved on to new musical pastures before their fans wanted them to but we’ll
come back to that later… This Is The Sea features nine tracks all of which are good though particular highlights
for me include the rocking Medicine Bow, scathing Be My Enemy and intense piano ballad Trumpets. Another highpoint also included is the band’s most famous track, the pounding, uplifting Whole Of
The Moon. A minor hit when originally released as a single the WOTM was a massive
top 5 hit when re-released in the early 90s, finally giving The Waterboys some much-deserved commercial success. The band
recorded many extra tracks for the This Is The Sea sessions, some of which finally saw the light of day on this Remastered
2CD Edition released in 2004. Some of these extra tracks – in particular
the Steve Reich influenced instrumentals by Scott and Karl Wallinger – are superfluous to say the least though there
are a couple of lost classics. Medicine Jack, the b-side to the original Whole
Of The Moon release and the thrilling Sleek White Schooner are the only tracks worthy of a place on the album proper. Both contain brilliant, exciting saxophone work by Anthony Thistlethwaite, who, along
with Wallinger, were the main lieutenants on Captain Scott’s merry crew during this period. The 2 CD Edition of This
Is The Sea also contains a fascinating if over-analytical essay by Scott about the album’s gestation. To get some idea of the level of detail involved, this piece even contains bullet points to highlight what
Mike learnt from his chief musical influences in shaping the album. Look into
the extensive song-by-song credits further though and the name Steve Wickham appears on violin on The Pan Within. A clue to where the Waterboys went next, Scott decamped to Ireland with Wickham soon after the release
of This Is The Sea and didn’t bring out another LP till the very different folk-influenced Fisherman’s Blues almost
three years later. Later in his weird and wonderful musical career, Mike Scott said that This Is The Sea represented the
culmination of the big music he strove to make to that point and he knew that he could only move in a different direction
after the LP’s release. He managed this successfully and, in so doing,
reinforced TITS’s standing as the pinnacle LP of the big music years and a classic, must-have release of its musical
era. Released: 2004 (Original album 1985) Acquired by me: 2007 – Present (Naomi)
Waterboys – Too Close To Heaven – The Unreleased Fisherman’s Blues Sessions **** In late 1985, Mike Scott went to Dublin for a week to stay with the brilliant fiddler and newest
Waterboys member Steve Wickham. He ended up staying in Ireland for six years! During the first two-and-a-half years, Scott, Wickham, Anthony Thistlethwaite, Trevor
Hutchinson and various other Waterboys and friends sporadically recorded an incredible mass of music – far more than
could be fitted onto the Fisherman’s Blues LP when it was finally released in 1988. After keeping the plethora
of unreleased material in the vaults for over a decade, Mike finally revisited the Fisherman’s sessions at the beginning
of the Millennium and released the first companion CD Too Close to Heaven in 2001. A
further CD of previously unheard gems was released in 2006 as apart of the Fisherman’s Blues Collectors Edition. Most of the tracks from Too Close To Heaven were recorded during the first year
of the Fisherman’s sessions and in many ways, they represent the missing link between the epic rock of This Is The Sea
and acoustic folk rock of the original Fisherman’s LP. Mike Scott is often
playing piano rather than acoustic guitar with Anthony Thistlethwaite usually on saxophone rather than mandolin. Blues For Your Baby was written by Scott as a tribute to his sax-playing friend and is fittingly included
on TCTH as Thistlethwaite is on brilliant form throughout the album. Not that it’s all Big Music though as the album
opens with the spritely country gospel of On My Way To Heaven, a live favourite from the Fisherman’s era finally released
in glorious studio format. This is followed by the absolute highlight Higher
In Time, a stunning, uplifting melody and lyric built around a surprisingly funky electric piano motif and one of my Top 10
Waterboys songs of all time. Other highlights of Too Close To Heaven include
the rare sense of regret by Scott in the Dylanesque Good Man Gone and the gospel soul of the title track though the latter
track is nowhere near to being interesting or varied enough to justify its 12 minute length.
Over-indulgence is of course one of Mike Scott’s traits and, though he does go too far at times, he wouldn’t
be half the artist he is without these flights of fancy. Although Too Close To Heaven includes a few such overbearing moments
and a couple of rather unmemorable songs, it is still a very worthy release. It
is also very nicely packaged with a short essay by Scott the archivist and commentary and musician credits for each song. An excellent souvenir and fascinating insight into the transition from rock to folk
roots music in the weird and wonderful journey of Mike Scott and The Waterboys. Released:
2001 Acquired by me: 11.1.006 – Present (for Naomi)
Waterboys - Universal Hall
****
Mike Scott has always seen The Waterboys as an adaptable band around his talents. There has been a new line-up to the
band on virtually every album. Of all the side players over the years, the one who has had the greatest influence on
Scott is the superb violinist Steve Wickham and on Universal Hall, they are reunited for the first time in over a decade.
Although
there is great variety in Scott's work, each Waterboys album can generally be filed as one of two types - intense, electric
rock or a more acoustic folk / rock sound. Not surprisingly, Universal Hall is in the latter category. Whatever
the sound, Mike's lyrics have always had a strong spiritual quality - even more so than usual on this LP.
On several tracks, the lyrics
consist of just a few lines repeated throughout the song. This sparseness sounds
lazy but is highly effective and hypnotic, emphasising the spirituality of standout tracks such as Christ In You and Every
Breath Is Yours. Other highlights on the album include the epic title track and
Peace Of Iona. Although some of the other songs are not so immediately
memorable, the sparse, intimate arrangements and clear production make Universal Hall a warm, cohesive album. Unlike many of his 80s peers, the visionary Scott is still making excellent, highly personal music after
all these years. Recommended.
Released - 2003
Acquired by me: 2.04 - Borrowed (Library)
Weller, Paul - Heavy Soul **** Rawer, more rocky and influenced by late 60s
guitar rock than other Weller albums, Heavy Soul still has some excellent songs, singing, playing and exciting moments as
well as a good live feel. Released - 1997 Acquired by me: 8.10.01 - Borrowed (Library)
Weller, Paul – Hit Parade ****1/2 For the first time, Hit Parade brings together
the three ages of Weller onto a single CD. Featuring seven tracks by The Jam, six by the Style Council
and 10 by Paul as a solo artist, the compilation obviously only scratches the surface of Weller’s vast repertoire but
is a very good overview or greatest hits set by this major artist. Obviously virtually all of Paul’s biggest hits
are present on Hit Parade but are these necessarily his greatest and most significant songs? By and large,
they are with particular highlights for me including The Eton Rifles and Town Called Malice by The Jam, the brilliant Shout
To The Top by the Style Council and Changingman and Wild Wood from the solo years. I imagine that Paul was especially thrilled
that two tracks from his (then) most recent LP As Is Now are also included on Hit Parade. Even more proudly,
the tracks in question – the exhilarating From The Floorboards up and Come On / Lets Go – stand up to anything
else featured on this compilation. The only real omissions from Hit Parade for me are singles representing Weller’s
early punk years (In The City would have been the best choice) and a track from his first solo album such as Into Tomorrow
which signified the beginning of his creative rebirth following the downward trajectory of the later Style Council years.
Neither song was a particularly big hit though they were highly significant releases and warrant inclusion on that
front. Good as Hit Parade is, it doesn’t really do Paul Weller justice in the way that a two CD set also including
further singles as well as key b-sides and album tracks would. Unfortunately Paul hasn’t been featured
in the excellent Essentials series yet so the best path for those wanting more Weller is a compilation of each of his three
main acts. For those just wanting a one-CD overview however, Hit Parade is a very good place to start. Acquired
by me: Autumn 2009 – Borrowed (Library)
White Stripes
– Elephant ***** How far can you develop your sound with just electric
guitar and drums. Quite a way though surely the point comes when your increasing
creativity and musicality demands the introduction of further instruments. On
Elephant, the White Stripes’ Jack White also plays piano, organ, acoustic guitar and bass though thankfully in a very
sparing way to enhance the songs. The raw White Stripes sound is still there
on this brilliant and exciting album. Like one of his clear influences Kurt Cobain, Jack knows about dynamics and how to
arrange a song featuring just a few parts to maximise it impact. He also share
Cobain’s gift for a good melody with virtually every song containing something particularly memorable to make the listener
want to play it again and again. For example, piano ballad I Want To Be The Boy
To Warm Your Mother’s Heart contains a glorious warms slide guitar solo whilst Hypnotize has an excellent bowed guitar
effect followed by an exciting drum-beat. Ah the drums! Although Jack is clearly
the main musical talent in the White Stripes, Meg White's drumming should not be overlooked.
Meg’s primal playing may be described by some as rudimentary yet it is highly effective in bringing real tension
to the White Stripes sound. Her style is similar to the Velvet Underground’s
Maureen Tucker with the art-rock of the VU another influence on the Stripes in general – particularly in the spoken
intro. to the bizarre Little Acorns. Further highlights of Elephant include the tracks most casual listeners are likely
to know - the fantastic singles Seven Nation Army and The Hardest Button To Button
as well as the band’s thrilling take on Bacharach and David’s I Just Don’t Know What To Do With Myself. Further highpoints include the incredible loud guitar solos on the lengthy Ball &
Biscuit and catchy organ work on The Air Near My Fingers. At the time of Elephant’s release, I believe that there
was still a lot of intrigue about the nature of Jack and Meg’s relationship, a ruse cleverly exploited by the duo and
their people for their own publicity. They play with these rumours further on
the closing cod-country track, Well It’s True That We Love One Another, which also features guest vocalist Holly Golightly. As it happens, the truth was stranger than fiction when it was finally revealed
that Jack and Meg were not a current couple nor brother and sister but an ex-married couple!
Quite bizarre… A bizarre and very individual band perhaps but certainly an excellent one. Elephant is the best new music I’ve heard for a good while with the White Stripes broadening their
musical palette without sacrificing their sound. A thrilling and fantastic punky
blues ride. Released: Acquired by me: 4.07 – Borrowed (Library)
Whittle, Jonathan – Mythology
****1/2 Jonathan Whittle has been composing and recording
(mostly) instrumental music since at least the early 90s as well as playing with a number of live and studio-based bands. His latest album Mythology is probably his best release yet. Jon’s solo sound
is built around heavily effected electric guitar and keyboards backed by electronic drums and bass. His bass parts are always interesting and often hold the compositions together which is not really
surprising bearing in mind that the four-string guitar is Jon’s first instrument. Jon is getting better and better
at moulding these components together to create memorable melodic pieces which are not over-cluttered by too many parts. On Mythology, he also uses vocal samples to great effect including a female soul voice
on the rave-like Snakes In Your Bed. He also skilfully employs some classic quotes
from a film adaptation of George Orwell’s 1984 in Thought Police though I feel that this song would be even more effective
if the drums were as harsh as the sentiments a la Radiohead circa Kid A. Other highlights from Mythology include Wonderful
Journey with its triumphant keyboard melody and the seductive, glacial Night Of A Thousand Kisses though the best track of
all is possibly right at the end of the LP. Green Light Signalling, Celestial
Light Answering is surely influenced by The Orb from the title onwards. It is
actually based on a recurring dream which Jon frequently has but can also be interpreted as a slightly quirky yet glorious
evocation of a beautiful morning including bird song and an alarm clock. A fine way to end an excellent album of strong
melodies and arrangements, Mythology was recorded in the Blue Room at Milton Keynes and can be obtained from Jon via jandewhittle@talktalk.net – it is highly recommended.
Released: 2009 Acquired by me: Present (From Jon) 4.09
Who - The Who Sell Out **** 60s Who album recorded as a tribute to pirate
radio. Nicely reissued with some excellent extra tracks. A bit inconsistent but theres superb, exciting musical interplay
and a handful of great songs. Released - 1967 (original release) Acquired by me: 19.9.00 - Borrowed (Library)
Who, The –
Tommy (Deluxe Edition) ***** I read recently that The Who thought that Tommy
was unfinished and wanted to add more electric guitar but time and financial constraints dictated otherwise. If this is the case, then lets be thankful for once to the schedulers as the sparseness of the arrangements
play a major role in making Tommy such a brilliant album. The strengths of Tommy are many.
Musically it contains a fine selection of melodic songs with brilliant harmonies and superb playing in particular by
Pete Townsend (often on acoustic guitar) and John Entwhistle on sympathetic melodic bass – before he felt the need to
over-complicate his playing. Add to this Entwhistle’s effective, occasional
brass hangings, Roger Daltrey’s vocals and Keith Moon’s spectacular but not yet over-indulgent drumming and you
have a band at the absolute peak of their powers. Then of course there are the
lyrics… Not quite the first rock opera but definitely the best, Tommy tells the story of a traumatised “deaf,
dumb and blind kid” who suffers horrendous abuse before he is amazingly cured as a young adult and is subsequently treated
as something of a Messiah, a role he ultimately rejects. The story looks at religion,
fame, exploitation and so much more though, unlike Pink Floyd’s The Wall, the lyrical concepts don’t weigh the
album down with weariness due to some wit in the words and the strength of the music. Virtually every song on Tommy is
excellent though some particular highlights for me range from the famous Pinball Wizard and We’re Not Gonna Take it
to the lesser know Christmas and Cousin Kevin via the Overture and Underture instrumentals.
The Deluxe Edition contains a second disc of out-takes and demo's including the band joking through Sally Simpson and
the fairground organ instrumental demo of Tommy’s Holiday Camp. All brilliant stuff, enhanced further, as already
noted, by the acoustic sparseness of the arrangements. Tommy finds The Who at the absolute intellectual, artistic and musical
peak of their powers. Far reaching yet accessible, it is a sure-fire classic
which should find a place in any serious music fan’s collection. Released:
2004 Acquired by me: 25.9.07 (Present - From Mum)
Wonder, Stevie - Innervisions **½ Classic
70s album including the famous Living For The City and Higher Ground. None of the other tracks really grabbed my attention.
Rather of it's time musically and lyrically and obviously not to my taste at the time of acquisition even though loads of
other people love it. Released - 1973 Acquired by me: 16.9.99 - Borrowed (Library)
|